While on some level, OK, most levels, I agree that rampant consumerism is not the most desirable way to live, I'm often left wondering what that means. What would happen if we all just stopped buying shit? Of course, we're getting a taste of that right now with the a worldwide recession. But what's bad about it? I think from an earth perspective, it's bad. We can't keep growing and consuming indefinitely and not expect the earth to suffer. But I never hear that argument. It's always just a general lament that we buy and buy and buy.When people criticize our consumer nature (and usually those critics don't have the means to buy buy buy) what are they striving for? It's easy to say, "We buy too much crap as Americans and using consumerism to offset terrorism was really shallow." But what else? What would take consumerisms place? Are we trying to get back to some ideal time? Are we going after some Pol Pot-esque "Year Zero"? Go agrarian? Go "Leave It to Beaver"? Some mystical days of yore?
I think if we can create sustainable consumerism, fine. If we can make cars that use a fraction of the fuel (petroleum or otherwise), if we can do away with plastice or drastically lower its use, stop littering and polluting, recycling, we'd be far better off.







